NCAA News Archive - 2006

« back to 2006 | Back to NCAA News Archive Index

Control of athletics must involve FARs


Dec 4, 2006 1:01:01 AM

By Brett Hunkins, Northwood University and Kurt Fuelhart, Shippensburg University of Pennsylvania

Enhancing the faculty athletics representative’s role on campus promotes student-athlete well-being while supporting integrity in the operation of the athletics department and its relationship to the campus and larger communities. We believe the achievement of those goals is almost universally recognized as essential to the mission of NCAA member institutions.

However, achieving that objective is complicated by the fact that there is no specific road map for FARs or institutions to follow.

NCAA Constitution 6.1.3 requires all member institutions to designate a faculty member to serve as its faculty athletics representative. Importantly, the section concludes by saying "Duties of the faculty athletics representative shall be determined by the member institution."

It is this ambiguity to which the Faculty Athletics Representatives Association — a group to which FARs from all three divisions may belong — and the NCAA have directed much attention. FARA has established a Web site FARs may use to help execute their duties.

In a related initiative, the Division II FAR Fellows Institute is a significant opportunity for Division II FARs to learn what duties FARs on other campuses perform, and the best practices associated with performing them.

Perhaps the most significant aspect of those efforts is that they help new FARs develop, as efficiently as possible, job descriptions on their respective campuses. All FARs report a substantial learning curve in the position; accordingly, any efforts to reduce that learning curve are useful and important.

The second annual Division II FAR Fellows Institute was in Indianapolis October 14-16. The institute, fully funded by the NCAA, provided 18 FARs from Division II institutions the opportunity to spend a weekend together exchanging ideas about the FAR role in general and developing best practices for establishing a meaningful FAR presence on campus.

The FARs who attended the institute have been charged with communicating the content, particularly the best practices, to other FARs in the conferences represented by the attendees. In this way, the presence of the FAR should be magnified on campus and within the respective conferences.

FARA’s executive committee has been instrumental in the organization’s efforts, and a persistent advocate of FARs to the NCAA. At the institute in Indianapolis, FARA Division II Vice President Bob Ziegenfus of Kutztown University of Pennsylvania reported that the NCAA has fully granted FARA’s budget request for the coming year. The NCAA deserves tremendous credit for its financial support of FARA and the resultant empowerment of the faculty athletics representative to develop and fulfill a meaningful role on campus.

We believe that the NCAA also must provide strong leadership by establishing accountability for institutions that do not have a meaningful FAR presence on campus.

NCAA President Myles Brand called on institute attendees to be effective agents for institutional control and academic integrity within the athletics department. We think it is obvious that FARA has taken this challenge seriously and is providing adequate guidance for individual FARs to take it seriously as well.

There is an unanswered question in all of this, and it must be answered by the NCAA. Namely, what can an FAR do if the institution does not empower her or him in a way sufficient to achieve the high ideals the NCAA believes the FAR should strive to see attained?

For now, the process works as follows: (a) The NCAA requires institutions to appoint an FAR, and (b) the FAR works within the institution to ensure compliance with NCAA regulations, achieve student-athlete well-being goals and maintain academic integrity.

While part (b) is exceptionally broad, the NCAA’s efforts to ensure FARs have access to best practices makes it manageable. However, there is no part (c) in the chain to describe what follows an absent or ineffective part (b). More importantly, there is nothing that forces part (b) to take place on a campus.

In this light, the NCAA’s charge to the FAR may be an empty one. At minimum, there currently is no way for the NCAA to ensure it isn’t.

The NCAA has expressed reluctance to legislate part (c) to its member institutions, arguing instead that it does legislate through its broad requirement of institutional control, while leaving the nuts and bolts to be determined at the campus level. However, some level of institutional control can likely be achieved without faculty representation. Institutional control that meaningfully involves the FAR is a different sort of institutional control with regard to the overall alignment of the athletics department within the university.

Of course, it certainly is true that the NCAA should not be involved in formulating specific acts for FARs to follow. Its support of FARA effectively removes that duty from the NCAA and places it at the institution and conference level. Nonetheless, requiring institutions to have the FAR involved in a meaningful way seems to be a required step for the FAR to achieve what the NCAA wishes.

Concurrently, it must be recognized that there is substantial space between legislating to institutions and leaving institutions unfettered. Said another way, there is a difference between not biting and being toothless. Ultimately, the NCAA must reconcile its twin desires to have strong FAR involvement in an autonomous campus operation.

We encourage further discussion of this issue and believe such discussion is necessary. FARs play a significant role in many institutions, including at Northwood University and Shippensburg University of Pennsylvania. With leadership from the NCAA, they could play such a role in all of them.

Brett Hunkins is the faculty athletics representative at Northwood University in Midland, Michigan, and Kurt Fuellhart is the faculty athletics representative at Shippensburg University of Pennsylvania.


© 2010 The National Collegiate Athletic Association
Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy