NCAA News Archive - 2004

« back to 2004 | Back to NCAA News Archive Index

Safeguards panel reviews reduced event drug testing


Jul 19, 2004 4:21:45 PM


The NCAA News

Recent increases in the number of NCAA championships and postseason bowl games, as well as expansion of existing championships' brackets, is resulting in drug testing of fewer student-athletes at specific events. The reduction ensures that testing occurs at least once every five years at every championship.

As a result, the Committee on Competitive Safeguards and Medical Aspects of Sports has recommended an increase in the drug-testing budget for 2005-06 to keep pace with inflation. The group also reviewed projected costs of increasing testing from the current level of 1,500 student-athletes per year during its June 25-27 meeting in Key West, Florida.

The National Center for Drug Free Sport, which conducts testing of those 1,500 participants under a contract with the Association, reported to the committee that it is selecting fewer student-athletes at specific events for testing, to ensure that each of 88 current NCAA championships and 28 postseason bowl games is tested at least once within five years.

For example, after devising a testing plan for the 2003-04 championships consistent with that five-year commitment, Drug Free Sport determined it would have to dramatically decrease the number of student-athletes tested at each selected championship event, to remain within the limit of 1,500. It subsequently reduced the number of individual tests conducted at various championships in each division to remain within the limit.

The percentage of student-athletes participating in championships who are tested also has declined through the years. In 1992-93, about 14 percent of championships participants (about 3,000 of 21,000 participants) were tested; in 2001-02, about 3 percent (about 1,500 of 49,000 participants) were tested. Some believe the reduction in the percentage tested at championship events threatens to undermine the deterrent effect of NCAA drug testing.

Drug Free Sport has estimated it would cost about $300 per test to expand the number of tests from the current level of 1,500. A 500-test increase would cost about $150,000.

The information was received by CSMAS' drug-education and drug-testing subcommittee, one of two subgroups that met during the committee meeting.

Handbook guideline

The committee's other subgroup, the sports sciences safety subcommittee, approved a new guideline for inclusion in the NCAA Sports Medicine Handbook addressing "catastrophic incidents."

The guideline recommends that NCAA member institutions develop their own Catastrophic Incident Guideline for providing information and support to family members, teammates, coaches and staff members following a catastrophe, which the guideline defines as "the sudden death of a student-athlete, coach or staff member from any cause, or a disabling and/or quality-of-life altering injury."

The guideline also recommends that an institutional plan include establishment of a management team, an action plan including a call list and initial steps, delineation of a chain of command and roles for involved individuals, and guidance in working with such authorities as law enforcement officers, or with officials at away contests.

The guideline will become the 32nd to be included in the handbook. Example policies based on the guideline can be found online at www.ncaa.org/health-safety.

Legislation

CSMAS also reviewed recently adopted Division I legislation for potential impact on institutional sports medicine staffs, based on the committee's ongoing concern about increasing demands on personnel that result from expanded medical coverage needs.

The committee cited three recently adopted legislative proposals that potentially will affect sports medicine staffs.

Proposal No. 03-139, which was adopted by the Division I Board of Directors as emergency legislation to provide medical expenses to student-athletes regardless of whether an injury or illness is athletics related, potentially will affect staffs as student-athletes initially report injuries or illnesses to sports medicine personnel.

Proposal 03-121, which permits a certified strength and conditioning coach to conduct conditioning workouts during an institution's vacation period, potentially will require the presence of sports medicine personnel during the workouts.

Also, similar demands potentially could result from the adoption of Proposal No. 03-86, which permits a strength and conditioning coach to conduct voluntary workout programs for prospective basketball student-athletes who either have signed a National Letter of Intent or been accepted for regular, full-time enrollment at an institution and are receiving financial aid to attend summer school.

CSMAS emphasized the need to take such demands into account during consideration of new rules and policies.

The committee also reviewed other recently adopted or proposed Division I legislation, and took the following actions:

  • Recommended to member institutions, in response to an amendment of Proposal No. 03-22, that they provide a "hard copy" of the NCAA banned-substances list to prospective student-athletes in addition to providing a Web address for an online version of the list as required by the legislation.

  • Expressed concern about the adjustment in the preseason football conditioning model enacted with adoption of Proposal No. 2003-119, which was approved after only one year of use of the model. The committee also expressed concern about a pending proposal to allow a "walk-through" during the five-day acclimatization period, noting that the original model was designed to provide adequate time for 90 minutes of practice (the optimal time for acclimatization) and also provide adequate time for logistical matters, including walk-throughs and on-field teaching sessions.

    Other actions

    In other actions involving drug education and drug testing, the committee:

  • Approved the final draft of this year's Drug Use Survey, which will be conducted this fall. This year's edition of the survey will include questions regarding use of medications for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). The resulting study will focus on substance use among Division III student-athletes, as the committee prepares to consider whether to recommend year-round drug testing in Division III.

  • Agreed to create educational materials for use by the membership regarding NCAA medical-exceptions policies, citing a reported increase in use of ADHD medications by student-athletes.

  • Endorsed conducting a membership survey to study frequency of harassment and discrimination in athletics departments based on individuals' actual or perceived sexual orientation and gender nonconformity. The survey also would seek to identify athletics departments' nondiscrimination and harassment policies and institutional resources for education and support.

  • Reviewed evaluations and feedback for drug-education programs. Among actions resulting from the review were recommendation of an increase in the number of CHOICES grants, from 10 to 15 annually; expansion of the Speaker Grant program to include a fifth topic, hazing; continuing support for the Techniques for Effective Alcohol Management (TEAM) Coalition; and a recommendation that a manual addressing recruiting and campus visits developed through the Athlete Prevention, Programming and Leadership Education (APPLE) model program be made available online to the NCAA membership.

  • Discussed issues related to incorporating all-sport testing into the year-round drug-testing program, and agreed to assist in addressing rules-compliance issues raised in the transition.

    In other actions involving sports sciences safety, the committee:

  • Endorsed convening a summit meeting addressing Commotio Cordis, a syndrome resulting from a blunt impact to the chest leading to cardiac arrest that was cited by doctors in the death last season of a lacrosse student-athlete at Cornell University. The summit would include representatives of the lacrosse and youth baseball communities, NCAA, National Athletic Trainers' Association, American College of Sports Medicine, American Medical Society for Sports Medicine and research experts.

  • Endorsed US Lacrosse's efforts to seek third-party testing of lacrosse eyewear to meet the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standard for impact.

  • Recommended to the NCAA Divisions I, II and III Field Hockey Committees that they consult with manufacturers to identify or develop eyewear that provides optimal protection for field hockey players while permitting extended vision.

  • Reviewed various sports science research studies, and recommended funding for studies addressing heat stress, eating disorders, and automated external defibrillator (AED) use.

  • Discussed variations among institutions in emergency-care policies for regular and nontraditional seasons, emphasizing adequate game coverage for contact and collision sports (for example, men's lacrosse) in all three divisions. Game-injury rates are considerably higher in these types of sports, and appropriate medical personnel (for example, certified athletic trainers) should be available. The committee endorsed continuing efforts to encourage adequate medical coverage through discussions with coaches and athletics administrators, and to promote adherence to current NCAA Sports Medicine Handbook guidelines.

  • Agreed to continue working with NCAA staff to evaluate the possibility of developing a coalition of member institutions seeking secondary insurance policies for athletics and pursuing reduced costs for such coverage.

    Also, the committee recommended the selection of Michael Krauss, head team physician at Purdue University, to serve as CSMAS chair, succeeding Matt Mitten of Marquette University beginning in September 2005


  • © 2010 The National Collegiate Athletic Association
    Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy