NCAA News Archive - 2004

« back to 2004 | Back to NCAA News Archive Index

New format keys fencing committee talks
Committee also discusses proposal for separate championships


Aug 2, 2004 3:04:54 PM


The NCAA News

Issues surrounding the new regional format that will go into effect with the 2005-06 season were among topics discussed by the NCAA Men's and Women's Fencing Committee at its July 7-10 meeting in San Diego.

In discussing the new regional format, committee members decided that the national qualifier will be based on the following:

  • Regionals will serve as the first round of competition to qualify for the national championships.

  • The regular season will be used only for seeding purposes.

  • There will be two at-large seeds considered from each region based on the power rankings. Secondary criteria will be used in case of a tie.

    The committee will send information to the membership concerning the regional qualification and format changes for 2005-06 to give coaches an opportunity for review and time to prepare for the changes.

    Also, the committee has requested that a $3,500 stipend be available beginning in 2005-06 for an institution to host a regional event. The committee is awaiting final budget approval from the Executive Committee.

    Committee members also agreed to the following format and criteria for each region to qualify participants to the regional tournaments, effective in 2004-05:

  • Each fencer must compete in a minimum of 20 bouts and meet the minimum power rating.

  • Each institution can enter a minimum of three fencers per event.

  • If the field of fencers per weapon is fewer than 36, additional fencers ranked according to their power ranking and who meet the 20-bout minimum will be added up to the maximum of 36.

    Each region will use a pool format that includes a minimum of one round of pools to advance to the final.

    Also, institutions must submit an entry form by the required deadline for their student-athletes to qualify for the regional championships.

    In addition to discussing the new regional format, the committee also took action regarding the 2005 championships. Members decided that competition on Friday and Saturday will begin at 9:30 a.m. instead of 10 a.m. The committee also discussed regional allocations for each weapon.

    The 2005 regionals, scheduled for March 5 and/or 6, will be held as follows:

  • Midwest -- Wayne State University (Michigan).

  • Northeast -- Hunter College.

  • West -- Stanford University.

  • Mid-Atlantic/South -- To be determined.

    Call for split championship

    The committee discussed a recommendation from fencing coaches to split the men's and women's championships into two events, as was the case before 1990 when the events became a single National Collegiate championship.

    Committee members noted that currently, nine of 43 institutions that sponsor fencing offer single-gender or mixed programs, which means that 21 percent of the institutions eligible for participation in the championships have no expectation of ever being awarded the national title. Additionally, two of these programs are single-gender schools that do not even have the option of fielding both a men's and women's team.

    Since the fencing championships were combined in 1990, no institution that offers a single-gender or mixed program has been among the top four finishers in any year.

    The Division I Championships/Competition Cabinet's bracket and format subcommittee did not support the committee's previous recommendation to provide awards within gender categories in February 2002. Therefore, fencing committee members say the only recourse is to recommend the separation of the championships, since that would appear to be the only way the national championship can be attainable by all sponsoring institutions.

    The committee also noted that no additional officials would be required -- the championships would be administered as they are now, with two days for each gender, and regionals would continue to be concurrent for both genders. The only additional cost would be one set of four team trophies.

    The committee also recommends that a single committee continue to administer both championships.

    Committee members agreed to forward the idea of a split championship to the Championships/Competition Cabinet as a "discussion item."

    In other action, the committee recommended that Kristen Foley, assistant athletics director/senior woman administrator at Temple University, be named the next chair. Foley would replace Sherry Posthumus, assistant athletics director at Stanford University, whose term on the committee expires in September.


  • © 2010 The National Collegiate Athletic Association
    Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy