« back to 2004 | Back to NCAA News Archive Index
|
Wrestling will honor its past at the 75th annual Division I championships March 17-19 in St. Louis by unveiling an all-time anniversary team, while casting a concerned eye toward the future of the sport.
Legendary names such as Dan Gable, Stan Henson and Dan Hodge sprinkle the ballot on the National Wrestling Coaches Association Web site (www.nwcaonline. com), where fans can vote through January 12 on who belongs on college wrestling's elite team. The results will be released during a March 18 ceremony between the morning and afternoon sessions of the NCAA tournament.
The NCAA and NWCA collaborated on the idea, and wrestling historians narrowed the list down to 45 names split among three categories -- lightweight, middleweight and heavyweight. There are 15 wrestlers in each category, and the top five vote-receivers in each will have a place on the all-time team.
As with any sport, it is hard to compare eras, and there always will be debate about why someone was left off the ballot.
Jay Hammond, a graduate of Lehigh University and an avid follower of the sport since 1962, was the man who first began constructing the list of nominees.
"I originally had 80 names,'' said Hammond, who plans to release a book titled "The History of College Wrestling" next fall. "Anyone who was a three- or four-time champion was included on the (initial) list. Anyone who was a two-time champion and had some other recognition, such as being named the most outstanding wrestler or if they won 90 percent of their bouts, I included them on the list. I wasn't totally arbitrary. I used guidelines, and I didn't include anybody who was a one-time champion."
A committee of six people pared the nominees to the final groups.
"There were five three-time national champions who didn't make the cut,'' Hammond said.
Grappling with debate
"What you have to do is not take this too seriously,'' said Mike Chapman, the executive director of the International Wrestling Institute and Museum in Newton, Iowa. "People on the committee can't, and the fans can't. It's just a good point for people to discuss the sport they love.''
Chapman was chosen to serve on the committee because of his resume, which includes attending 36 NCAA championships and writing 12 books on the sport. He also has talked at length with some of the top wrestlers and coaches through eras dating back to the early days when the NCAA first sponsored wrestling.
"If you want to make this a precise science, you can't,'' Chapman said. "If your viewpoint is to have fun, create excitement about the sport and get people talking in friendly debates, this is a way to do it.''
The NWCA is pleased with the attention this project has sparked.
"The feedback has been tremendous,'' said Pat Tocci, the director of administration and public relations for the NWCA. "It has generated a lot of interest within the wrestling community. It's been talked about on forums, and we've received a lot of e-mails.''
Every two weeks, the ballot on the NWCA Web site changes categories. Everyone involved in the project knows fans are likely to vote for the men they've seen in person. This might not bode well for pioneers of the sport who competed before World War II.
"Stan Henson, by most people, is considered to be the greatest wrestler in the pre-war period,'' Hammond said. "But I'm sure most people haven't a clue as to who Stan Hansen is. They can see his record, but they will likely vote for someone with name recognition. It's like any other sort of election. Even if we put in their credentials, people will vote for the names they recognize. They just don't know about the other wrestlers.''
Looking ahead
Honoring the past has been a positive for all who support wrestling at all levels. However, there is concern about the future because of the number of institutions that have cut programs in recent years. Some cite wrestling programs as victims in institutional efforts to comply with Title IX, while others say tightening budgets have had a negative impact on nonrevenue or Olympic sports.
"Title IX has made a big dent in (wrestling sponsorship),'' said Ron Good, the editor of the Amateur Wrestling News. "A lot of colleges have dropped the sport, but there is a woman (Audrey Pang) who is wrestling at Princeton at 125 pounds. You have women wrestling in the Olympics. I think the sport is strong when you look down to the high schools.''
But many in the college wrestling community are concerned about the welfare of the sport on college campuses.
"We've never had more postgraduates staying around to wrestle,'' Chapman said. "We're extremely successful in the high schools and junior highs. Only at the college level is it down. It's Title IX, plain and simple. Title IX was desperately needed in the 1970s. Women weren't getting a fair shake then. This is not about men vs. women. It's about simply saying that you can't drop programs for any reason without exploring every single option.
"The fewer men's programs there are means there are fewer necessities for women's programs, because Title IX demands the numbers be equal."
The NWCA sued the U.S. Department of Education in 2002, challenging the proportionality prong of Title IX. The lawsuit, which eventually was dismissed, claimed a 1996 ruling prompted colleges and universities to discriminate against men's teams.
The heightened attention to Title IX, though, prompted the appointment of a national Commission on Opportunity in Athletics, which held several "town-hall" meetings during which the effects of Title IX on college sports were debated.
In July 2003, the U.S. Department of Education ended more than a year of speculation about potential changes to Title IX when it announced that it was committed to a policy of "continuing the progress that Title IX has brought toward true equality of opportunity for male and female student-athletes in America."
The statement also said that the Department of Education would view the elimination of men's teams as a "disfavored practice" for achieving Title IX compliance. No changes were made to the current three-pronged test for Title IX compliance.
Since then, the NCAA and the United States Olympic Committee have combined to form a task force to address the enhancement of Olympic sports. That group's final recommendations are expected within the next year.
Chapman said he understands the challenges ahead.
"Again, this is not men vs. women," Chapman said. "I have two daughters, and Dan Gable has four daughters, and no one is saying women shouldn't have equal opportunity. We just think the way to get there isn't to drop men's sports. That's all we're saying.
"It's going to take enlightened leadership at the NCAA level to stop the carnage.''
On the Ballot
Lightweight (top five vote-receivers will be selected)
Middleweight (top five vote-receivers will be named)
Heavyweight (top five vote-receivers will be named)
© 2010 The National Collegiate Athletic Association
Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy